Sponsored by BRS Backyard Bug Busters ›.jfif)
TJ's Pizza Cafe
Fresh, affordable pizza and Italian fare that keeps locals coming back to Marshall Hill Road.
Seven years is a long time to be someone's go-to. Ask the regulars on Marshall Hill Road and they'll tell you TJ's earns that loyalty one pie at a time. The dough is fresh, the sauce is housemade, and nothing on the menu reads like it came out of a freezer bag.
The Chipotle Chicken Pie alone has built a following. It's the kind of specialty pizza that makes you question why you ever ordered plain cheese. But the classics hold their own too, whether it's a crispy thin crust margherita or a loaded stromboli that barely fits in the box. People who've spent their careers in the pizza business say TJ's Pizza Cafe is spot on, and that's not a compliment handed out lightly in North Jersey.
The woman behind the register knows regulars by name and remembers orders. That detail matters more than most menus. West Milford is a tight-knit community, and TJ's fits it perfectly, friendly, no-frills, and genuinely good.
TJ's runs a full Italian-American menu built around one promise: real food at prices that don't sting. The pizza program is the anchor, with traditional pies, specialty creations like the Chipotle Chicken Pie, white pies, and Sicilian slices that hit the spot on a weeknight or a Friday night rush.
Beyond pizza, the kitchen turns out pasta dishes, calzones, strombolis, subs, and appetizers that round out any order. Meal delivery covers the surrounding West Milford area, so you can get a full family dinner to your door without leaving the couch. Online ordering is available through the website for pickup and delivery alike.
Catering and large orders are welcome. Call (973) 728-2228 ahead and the team will make sure your order is ready on time and exactly right.
Take a look at our space and what we have to offer
Don't just take our word for it - hear from our satisfied customers
TJ's Pizza Cafe is at 18 Marshall Hill Rd, West Milford, NJ 07480. Easy to reach from most neighborhoods in the West Milford area.
Yes. TJ's offers meal delivery to the surrounding West Milford area. You can place a delivery order by calling (973) 728-2228 or through the website at tjspizzeriacafe.com.
The Chipotle Chicken Pie gets mentioned constantly by regulars and is widely considered one of the best specialty pizzas in the area. Classic pies, strombolis, and pasta dishes are also customer favorites.
Yes. Online ordering for pickup and delivery is available through the TJ's website at tjspizzeriacafe.com.
For large orders or catering, call ahead at (973) 728-2228 so the team can prepare everything fresh and have it ready on time.
TJ's is a full Italian-American cafe with pasta dishes, calzones, strombolis, subs, and appetizers rounding out the menu alongside a wide variety of pizzas.
For current hours, visit tjspizzeriacafe.com or call (973) 728-2228 directly. Hours can vary by season and holiday.
Hand-picked local businesses near here, surfaced by NearByMeNow. Click any card to explore the full directory.